I just finished reading Fahrenheit 451 and did exactly what the author despises to his book. I have marked every curse word that I don't believe should be used in literature for children or young adults with yellow/green tabs, marked all sexual or suicide references with purple and scenes with what I feel inappropriate subject matter with pink tabs. I find it ironic that have done exactly what the author is writing to fight against.
Originally, I did an observation of a blended middle school classroom of both 7th and 8th graders. This observation went fine in the since there were no red flags rising from the ashes as the class read aloud. I was intrigued...so I asked the librarian for a copy. At lunch she delivered my copy and another teacher asked why I wanted it. I explained I was interested and wanted to see what the students were reading. She proceeded to tell me that book was inappropriate and had a hooker in it. At this point I became concerned and more interested in reading the book to see whether there was or not.
To put all minds at ease there isn't...however, some of the content seems inappropriate for a middle school student. And knowing that my daughter will be in our middle school in two years...I am a concerned mother. I wouldn't mind if this book was read in high school...I think students could understand the main concept and have perhaps an intellectual conversation about this typic and how it is related to society as a whole.
In contrast I don't feel that a 11-12 year old can really comprehend this books content without just seeing it as proof that they can say and do whatever they want. AGain, I know I am a rule follower and too controlling...but seriously, our student have enough real world issues do we really have to introduce suicide, overdosing, murder, sabotage, and so much more to their turbulent teen years?
All in all, I enjoyed reading the book...and think it could have a roll in a high school classroom...history or english....however, it should not have just been pulled off a shelf, because I read it a few years ago and can do a cool project with it...without a lot of careful and considerate planning. Least to say...my children won't be participating in this book when they are in that class. I truly believe there are other books worthy of their educational time and instruction.
The question now it what to do about it...do I pull the tabs and return it to the library or raise hell and contribute to what the author is trying to prevent in the first place.... I feel guilty on so many levels...